Introduction
The story of modern dispensationalism is not one of faithful exegesis but of invention, deception, and distortion. For nearly two millennia, the Church confessed one covenant people of God, Israel fulfilled in Christ and His Church. Then in the 19th century John Nelson Darby devised a new scheme, and C. I. Scofield spread it through his reference Bible. In the 20th century, three men in Dallas–Fort Worth made it mainstream: Lewis Sperry Chafer, J. Frank Norris, and W. A. Criswell.
These men institutionalized Scofield’s footnotes, thundered them from pulpits, and exported them through Baptist channels until millions of Christians confused the words of Scofield with the Word of God. Dallas–Fort Worth became the epicenter of dispensationalism, and its influence reshaped American evangelicalism.
The Historic Teaching Before the Lie
For the first 1,800 years of Christianity, the truth was uncontested: the Church is the continuation and fulfillment of Israel. The Fathers, the medievals, the Reformers — all agreed.
- Justin Martyr (c. 100–165): “For we are the true spiritual Israel, and the descendants of Judah, Jacob, Isaac, and Abraham.” (Dialogue with Trypho, ch. 11)
- Irenaeus (c. 130–202): “They who are of faith are the sons of Abraham, who has been appointed the father of all nations… they who follow the faith of Abraham receive the promises made to him.” (Against Heresies 4.21.1)
- Augustine (354–430): “The New Testament lies hidden in the Old, and the Old is unveiled in the New.” (Quaestiones in Heptateuchum 2.73)
- John Calvin (1509–1564): “All the children of the promise, scattered throughout the world, are reckoned as members of one and the same family.” (Institutes, 2.10.1)
The unity of God’s people was never in doubt. No credible theologian before Darby taught two separate peoples of God with two separate destinies.
The Ten Northern Tribes and the Mystery of the Church
The ten northern tribes of Israel were lost among the Gentiles in the Assyrian exile (2 Kings 17). Yet God promised restoration:
- Hosea 1:10 – “In the place where it was said to them, ‘You are not my people,’ it shall be said to them, ‘Children of the living God.’”
- Ezekiel 37:22 – “I will make them one nation in the land… and one king shall be king over them all.”
Paul explained how this restoration happens:
- Romans 9:24–26: He applies Hosea’s prophecy to Gentiles coming into the Church.
- Romans 11:25–26: “A partial hardening has come upon Israel, until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in. And in this way all Israel will be saved.”
The mystery is that the Gentiles, when grafted into Christ, fulfill the restoration of the lost tribes. Israel is not replaced but reconstituted. The Church is the restored Israel, Jew and Gentile united in Christ.
Darby and Scofield: The Fathers of the Lie
Darby devised the framework. Scofield spread it. His 1909 Reference Bible became the Trojan horse that smuggled dispensationalism into American Protestantism. With Oxford University’s imprint, it looked authoritative. With notes inserted into the biblical text, it looked inseparable from Scripture.
By the 1920s, countless preachers treated Scofield’s notes as divinely inspired commentary. The groundwork was laid for the lie to flourish.
Lewis Sperry Chafer and Dallas Theological Seminary (1924)
In 1924, Lewis Sperry Chafer, Scofield’s disciple, founded Dallas Theological Seminary. DTS was not simply another seminary — it was built for the explicit purpose of systematizing dispensationalism.
Chafer’s eight-volume Systematic Theology (1947–48) was the first complete dispensational systematic ever written. DTS graduates spread its doctrines far and wide. John Walvoord refined its eschatology; J. Dwight Pentecost mapped out its prophecy charts; Charles Ryrie popularized its distinctions in Dispensationalism Today.
DTS produced leading dispensationalists: John Walvoord, J. Dwight Pentecost, Charles Ryrie. Perhaps the most famous DTS graduate was Hal Lindsey, whose The Late Great Planet Earth (1970) sold over 15 million copies, becoming the best-selling nonfiction book of the decade. Lindsey’s book put dispensational prophecy on coffee tables across America, marrying Scofield’s footnotes with Cold War panic.
Through DTS, dispensationalism gained academic respectability, publishing muscle, and cultural reach.
Chafer himself was clear about his purpose:
“The dispensationalist believes that throughout the ages God is pursuing two distinct purposes: one related to the earth with earthly people and earthly objectives involved, which is Judaism; the other related to heaven with heavenly people and heavenly objectives involved, which is Christianity.” (Dispensationalism, p. 107)
Here lies the error: two peoples, two destinies, a division Scripture never makes.
J. Frank Norris and Arlington Baptist College (1939)
If Chafer gave the system its fortress, J. Frank Norris gave it fire.
Norris, the “Texas Tornado,” pastored First Baptist Fort Worth and Temple Baptist Detroit. He was a fundamentalist brawler, expelled from the SBC, but he wielded enormous influence. Through the World Baptist Fellowship, he founded Arlington Baptist College (ABC) in 1939.
ABC’s purpose was not scholarship but revival. It trained young preachers to storm pulpits with Scofield in one hand and prophecy charts in the other. Where DTS produced scholars, ABC produced revivalists. Norris ensured dispensationalism spread through independent Baptist churches, especially in Texas, Oklahoma, and the South.
W. A. Criswell and First Baptist Dallas (1944)
In 1944, W. A. Criswell became pastor of First Baptist Dallas, later the largest Southern Baptist church in the nation, and founder of Criswell College in 1970.
Criswell preached Scofield’s theology unapologetically:
“God deals with two peoples: Israel and the church. They are not the same, and they never merge.” (Expository Sermons on Revelation, 1960s)
As president of the Southern Baptist Convention (1968–70), Criswell’s influence extended across the denomination. Through him, Scofield’s dispensationalism became mainstream in the SBC, shaping Sunday school lessons, sermons, and missionary preaching.
By the 1950s, it was common for Texas laypeople to think they were quoting the Bible when in fact they were repeating Scofield’s commentary.
DFW as the Epicenter
With Chafer’s fortress at DTS, Norris’s grassroots army at ABC, and Criswell’s denominational megaphone at FBC Dallas, the Dallas–Fort Worth area became ground zero for American dispensationalism.
From there, the system spread through Southern Baptist churches, independent Baptist revivals, and later televangelist airwaves. By mid-century, DFW was not just another religious hub — it was the epicenter of a theological distortion..
Televangelists, Profit, and the Religion of Fear
If Chafer, Norris, and Criswell built the foundation, the televangelists paved the highway. Dispensationalism leapt from pulpits into living rooms through television screens.
Hal Lindsey made prophecy sensational. Jack Van Impe, Pat Robertson, and John Hagee amplified it further. They sold not only sermons but books, tapes, conferences, and “prophecy tours.” Critics long ago noted the pattern: fear was the product, and profit was the reward.
These men did not merely preach; they packaged panic. They created an economy of fear, continually pointing to headlines as proof of prophecy, always urging urgency, always selling the next installment. They enriched themselves while amplifying terror.
It is not slander to note what critics across theological and journalistic lines have observed: dispensational televangelism has been inseparable from commercial exploitation.
Yet the deeper problem is spiritual. Paul wrote: “For God has not given us a spirit of fear, but of power and of love and of a sound mind” (2 Tim 1:7). Fear-mongering prophecy preaching cultivates exactly what God forbids — a spirit of fear. It feeds greed in the preacher and panic in the congregation. It is, in truth, a work of darkness, doubly demonic: it exploits greed and enslaves hearers to fear.
The Political Consequence: Impunity for Israel
The political fruit of dispensationalism has been disastrous. Scofield and his heirs taught that the modern state of Israel (1948) was the fulfillment of prophecy. Misusing Genesis 12:3, they warned that nations must bless Israel or face God’s curse.
As a result, millions of American Christians now give Israel impunity, excusing injustice, ignoring the cries of Palestinians — including Palestinian Christians — and baptizing politics with false prophecy.
This is not covenant faithfulness but idolatry. It is the Church bowing to Scofield’s notes instead of Christ’s gospel.
What Was Forgotten
In embracing Scofield, many forgot Paul’s mystery. The ten northern tribes, lost among the Gentiles, are restored in the Church as Gentiles come to Christ. Judah too is grafted back in when Jews believe. In Christ, “all Israel” is restored, not in a strip of land but in the Kingdom of God.
They forgot the truth: the true Promised Land is the new creation, not political borders. The true Temple is Christ and His people, not a rebuilt shrine. The true Israel is Christ and His Church.
All of this was known to the Fathers, preached by the Reformers, and confessed by the historic Church. But dispensationalism replaced it with a lie.
Conclusion
Conclusion
Three men spread deception. Lewis Sperry Chafer institutionalized it at DTS. J. Frank Norris spread it through ABC. W. A. Criswell amplified it through First Baptist Dallas and the Southern Baptist Convention.
Then came the televangelists, who turned the deception into a television empire of fear and profit. Lindsey, Van Impe, Robertson, Hagee — they enriched themselves while feeding panic, exploiting two demonic forces: greed and fear. And those who heed them receive not the Spirit of God, but the spirit of fear, which God has not given, but comes from the deceiver.
The result? Millions of Christians blinded, mistaking Scofield’s notes for Scripture, mistaking a modern nation-state for God’s Kingdom, and excusing injustice and violence in the name of prophecy.
Christ is the true Israel, and in Him His Church is the restored people of God, the fulfillment of God’s promises. “For all the promises of God find their Yes in Him” (2 Cor 1:20).
For further reading:
Gods By Grace 
Leave a comment